Vegan Spice Sugar Cookies

These easy vegan spice sugar cookies are like gingerbread without molasses. Made with coconut sugar and ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg for a holiday worthy flavour without any hard to find ingredients. Easily rolled and cut, these make the prettiest Christmas cutout cookies in any shape you like. Skip to the recipe →

I think I realized today why it’s been so tricky to get into a holiday mood since we moved over here – it doesn’t get cold! It doesn’t feel like Christmas until there’s snow on the ground (lots of snow) and there’s been at least one cold snap. Maybe it’s something you get used to. Even without snow, baking little cutout sugar cookies makes things a bit more festive! I shot this recipe in September though, hah.

And good news! I hope! We saw a house for the second time yesterday and my fingers are crossed very tightly indeed in the hopes that we’ll get it. It seems likely this time around, finally. It needs some renovating and I’m thinking about sharing that as a separate section here on the blog as we’d be focusing on sustainable methods and products as much as possible.

How freaking cute is that donkey cookie cutter?! That one and the mushrooms are my favourite.

One bowl vegan sugar cookies

Best thing about these vegan spice sugar cookies, easily, is that everything is made in one bowl. You whisk the sugar, oil, and milk together before stirring in the dry ingredients, then knead a bit to bring everything together. No refrigeration needed here. You just mix, roll, and bake. If the dough seems a touch too wet just add a bit more flour and knead it in, no problem.

The type of flour you use can affect the dryness of the dough slightly, but it shouldn’t be too dry that it refuses to come together even after kneading or too wet to peel away from the paper when you cut the cookies. Rolling it out between paper is never a bad idea, but I do often make these and just roll them on a floured surface. These would be so fun to make with kids. 

Here’s my big tip for cutout cookies: don’t use tiny cookie cutters! I know they’re so cute, but it’s probably not worth your time or back pain to cut out a hundred mini cookies.

The method for these is simpler than previous recipes I’ve posted – for my vegan orange shortbread, you have to use a whack of liquid ingredients, then stick it in the fridge until it’s just right, but not too hard. Then you can roll. These spicy sugar cookies are crazy simple and yield a softer cookie.

Gingerbread without molasses

My goal was to make gingerbread, and these are essentially gingerbread cookies without molasses. You can’t really find it over here and I’m also not such a fan in any case. Coconut sugar gives a little caramel flavour, and ginger, nutmeg, and cinnamon add spiciness.

I’ve also left out coconut oil in favour of sunflower or grape seed to skip the step of melting the oil. The pretty colour of the cookies comes mostly from the coconut sugar.

They puff up quite a bit in the oven but shouldn’t really spread at all. If anything you might lose the form slightly when you move them onto the pan to bake – a good trick is to use a thin knife to lift the cookies instead of using your hands. They will get little rounded tops but that just makes them cuter, right?

I hadn’t really found a vegan sugar cookie recipe I loved before now, but these are great. You could top them with icing, or chocolate, but they’re great plain too. I sprinkled them with some coconut flour for the pictures because it’s a little sweet and looks just like powdered sugar.

You know what would be great on these? Some coconut yogurt labneh! It’d be just like a cream cheese icing, and it’s a great healthier plant-based alternative to regular icing.

More healthy cookie recipes

If you need a little more cookie inspiration, I have a pile of healthier cookie recipes! Check out these festive recipes:
Vegan Lebkuchen (German Spiced Cookies)
Chocolate Orange Macaroons
Honey Oat Cookies
Spicy Vegan Orange Shortbread
Raw Bounty Bars
Flourless Chocolate Tahini Cookies

Last year I shared a holiday cookie box, too, with some of my favourites packed into an admittedly messy looking box that I made out of paper and staples. It’s the thought that counts, right? I think these vegan spice cookies would make a really pretty food gift.

Let’s connect! If you liked these chickpea sweet potato burgers, make sure to leave a comment below, I love hearing from you! Tag me on instagram @occasionallyeggs and #occasionallyeggs so I can see what you’re making, and stay in touch via email, facebook, and pinterest.